Saturday, September 08, 2018

 

Warren using Family Lore of Native American Heritage For Employment

                                                                             
Nadene Goldfoot                                       
"Harvard Law School in the 1990s touted Warren, then a professor in Cambridge, as being "Native American." They singled her out, Warren later acknowledged, because she had listed herself as a minority in an Association of American Law Schools directory. Critics note that she had not done that in her student applications and during her time as a teacher at the University of Texas.
Warren maintains she never furthered her career by using her heritage to gain advantage.
"Warren’s central offense dates back to the mid 1980s, when she first formally notified law school administrators that her family tree includes Native Americans. Warren said she grew up with family stories about both grandparents on her mother’s side having some Cherokee or Delaware blood."
CNN's program with Smerconish today interviewed the interviewer of Elizabeth Warren and found that she had gone to college and Law school under no special ethnicity, just as a white.  Her maiden name was Elizabeth Ann Herring.  However, in getting a job with Harvard, she seemed to have an epiphany and embraced her heritage so listed herself as a Native American.  Then she got the job.  That certainly is using the racist card in employment.
Elizabeth said she based this fact of being a Native American on family lore. "Warren says, yes, she is, and points to "family stories" passed down to her through generations as evidence.
"I am very proud of my heritage," Warren told NPR in 2012. "These are my family stories. This is what my brothers and I were told by my mom and my dad, my mammaw and my pappaw. This is our lives. And I'm very proud of it."  
Elizabeth's ggrandfather was John Hayne Herring b: 1860 in Cornwall, England who immigrated from England in 1866 to Massachusetts, married to Mary Annie Scharan of Switzerland.  Elizabeth herself was born in 1949 in Oklahoma, the state where there is a large Indian Reservation. The Cherokee Nation had to walk in winter to Oklahoma in what is called "the Train of Tears." It's a well known story.   She married Jim Warren, a high school love.  Her grandfather was Grant Leslie Herring. .  
 We're related to the Warren family of Richard Warren (1578 England-1628 Massachusetts), 13th signer of the Mayflower Compact on our mother's father's side of the family with my grandfather, Frank Hugh Robinson, being his 7th ggrandson---if I have chosen the right father of Frank, for Robinson in New England is as common as fleas on a dog. 7 generations ago we had 128 ancestors with 64 females and 64 males and inherit only 0.78125% per ggggggrandparent.  This would take us back to 1841 just about, the date Elizabeth's ggrandfather Herring could have been born in England.   I've now had about 12 different theories as to who Frank's father was. This assumption was when I thought Cyrus B Robinson was Abiathar Smith Robinson's father, but since then, I've changed my mind.  Good bye Richard Warren's connection     Robinson and Warren  are common surnames.  That's if I did my genealogy research correctly.  I also found we're related to Harry Truman's wife, Bess, too. That's through my mother's mother's side, much easier whose surname was Tuller.    I found we're related to all of England's kings and queens as well.  All this needs to be verified by qualified genealogists if I wanted to be sure about it.  At least I know how hard I worked at it to accidentally bump into such well known people.  
A genealogist said that Elizabeth, if true and verified, would then be 1/32 Native American.  
I haven't read anywhere that she had a DNA test for proof, and that's really what she needs.  Family lore is just that; family lore.  This has to be proved.  DNA would show if she had native American genes.
We have Native American lore, too.  My grandfather said that his brother had married an Indian princess.  I can't find this anywhere.  It wouldn't make me having Native American genes, anyway.  
"I will give you a million dollars to your favorite charity, paid for by Trump, if you take the test and it shows you're an Indian," he said. "I have a feeling she will say no."
"Warren immediately shot back: "While you obsess over my genes, your Admin is conducting DNA tests on little kids because you ripped them from their mamas," she wrote on Twitter, a reference to the migrant children who have been separated from their parents at the southern border because of a Trump administration policy.
Guess what.  She used this lore to gain a special job at Harvard.  She used such guesswork to have power being she knew that this would put her at the head of a list.  It was what I all "lying."  You don't say you are a native American in this instance unless you have good proof.  I blame Harvard also for not checking her claim out.  They could have asked, who in your family was native American and what tribe?  People are known to lie on their resume and it's up to the business to check them out.  Guess what?  They figured a lawyer would have been honest.  Good grief!  From one DNA lab, her ethnicity was:  Ethnicity: English, Cornish, Swiss-German, Scottish, Welsh, Irish, Scots-Irish/Northern Irish, Swedish.  

"Elizabeth’s paternal grandmother was Ethel Virginia Jones (the daughter of Summerfield Jones and Sarah Frances/Francis Kerr). Ethel was born in Missouri. Sarah was the daughter of Matthew H. Kerr and Sarah Ann Elizabeth Ellis."  We also have a slew of Jones on our tree but no Ethel Virginia or others listed.  


"Elizabeth’s maternal grandfather was Harry Gunn Reed (the son of Joseph H. Reed and Charity Louise Gorman). Harry was born in Illinois. Joseph was the son of The Rev. Joseph H. Reed and Eliza Bell. Charity was the daughter of Ezekiel/Ezekial Tom Gorman and Matilda Elizabeth Matthews." Depending on which Robinson line, we do have a lot of Reeds that I have found.  I have several Joseph Reeds, but no Gormans.  We have 2 female Matthews.  
Elizabeth’s maternal grandmother was Bethania Elvina “Hannie” Crawford (the daughter of John Houston/Huston Crawford and Plina/Paulina/Paulliney Ann Bowen). Bethania was born in Missouri. John was the son of Preston H. Crawford and Edith May Marsh/March. Plina was the daughter of George Washington Bowen and Bethania/Bethany/Bethaney Clark..  We have a Virginia Crawford married to a Homer Robinson; tons of Bowens but none of hers; tons of Clarks but not hers.  

"Elizabeth has stated that she was told by her family, that one of her maternal great-great-great-grandmothers, Neoma Sarah Smith (popularly known as O.C. Sarah Smith), was of Cherokee Native American background. She has also stated that she has some degree of Delaware Native American ancestry. These statements, and their accuracy, were often the subject of media coverage during the 2012 Senate campaign in Massachusetts (where Elizabeth Warren was a candidate). Many of O.C. Sarah Smith’s ancestral lines have been traced to foreign-born (non-Native American) origins. To date, it appears that no genealogical evidence has been produced that Elizabeth Warren has Cherokee Native American ancestry."
Research:  https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/29/politics/elizabeth-warren-native-american-pocahontas/index.html
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/fact-check-trump-wants-warren-prove-her-native-american-heritage-n864446
https://www.geni.com/people/John-Herring/6000000017864843101
http://ethnicelebs.com/elizabeth-warren




Labels: , , , , , , , ,


Saturday, July 02, 2016

 

Richard Warren-13th signer of Mayflower Compact-Connection to Elizabeth Warren of 2016?

Nadene Goldfoot                                                                 
"Elizabeth Ann Warren is an American academic and politician. She is a member of the Democratic Party, and is the senior United States Senator from Massachusetts."   She was born June 22, 1949. Wikipedia

Elizabeth Warren is being considered as a vice President for Hillary Clinton.  She has been passing herself off as a native American, which turns out to not be true at all. This has angered a few native Americans about this lie of  "want-ta-be."  
                                                               
"The New England Historical Genealogical Society initially announced in May 2012 that they had found evidence for Warren's claims, but later recanted, saying, "We have no proof that Elizabeth Warren’s great great great grandmother O.C. Sarah Smith either is or is not of Cherokee descent." 
"For months, talk of Warren’s family has had a bitter, biting edge to it, following revelations that she had claimed a Native American heritage in employment forms and law teaching directories. She has said that her heritage claim, based on family lore and no documentation, did not bring her any ­career advantages." That claim would have had to be counting on her Herring or Reed ancestry, wherever this great great great grandmother, Sarah Smith had been a part of, and not her husband's Warren ancestry.  
On the 1817 Cherokee Reservation Roll Results info, I found# 357 William Reed that could be followed up.  None listed for Herring.  None listed for Warren.  Smith hit the jackpot, of course.  
List of Reservation
Res IDLastFirst
404 Smith Cabbin 
405 Smith Henry 
406 Smith Polly 
407 Smith Walter 

Elizabeth was born on June 22, 1949 in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma to Donald Jones Herring and his wife, Pauline Louise Reed.  Elizabeth Herring married Jim Warren, a NASA engineer,  and then divorced in 1978.  He had been her high school boyfriend.  She has since remarried Bruce Mann.
Her genealogy on her father's side is that her father, Donald Jones Herring, was born November 5, 1911 and died December 3, 1997 in Oklahoma.  He was the son of Grant Leslie Herring and Ethel Virginia Herring, maiden name not given.  He was the husband of Pauline Louise Herring and brother of Raymond G, Ruth Virginia and Jack W. Herring.  
Signing the Mayflower Compact: was Richard Warren.  Is he an ancestor of Elizabeth Warren's former husband, Jim Warren?
 
The Mayflower Compact, signed by 41 English colonists on the ship Mayflower on November 11, 1620,   was the first written framework of government established in what is now the United States.The compact was drafted to prevent dissent amongst Puritans and non-separatist Pilgrims who had landed at Plymouth a few days earlier.
John Carver                                                      Edward Tilley                                            Degory Priest
William Bradford                                                      John Tilley                                            Thomas Williams
Edward Winslow                                               Francis Cooke                                         Gilbert Winslow
      William Brewster                                               Thomas Rogers                                     Edmund Margesson
Isaac Allerton                                                     Thomas Tinker                                            Peter Brown  
      Myles Standish                                                 John Rigsdale                                         Richard Britteridge
John Alden                                                        Edward Fuller                                           George Soule
Samuel Fuller                                                     John Turner                                             Richard Clarke
Christopher Martin                                             Francis Eaton                                          Richard Gardiner
William Mullins                                                 James Chilton                                           John Allerton   
William White                                                    John Crackstone                                    Thomas English
Richard Warren                                                   John Billington                                           Edward Doty    
John Howland                                                    Moses Fletcher                                         Edward Leister
Stephen Hopkins 
                            Listed here are 40 of the 41 names.  I notice Richard Warren here is #12th to sign, and my records say he was #13.  That would be the 12th signer who is missing in the list.  The name, Clark/Clarke was a name on my tree that I had to wade through to reach this ancestor.  Hope I did it correctly.
                                                                 
Mayflower that sailed in 1620 
Our genealogy shows the Robinsons connecting to the famous Richard Warren (1578 -1628)  who was the 13th signer of the Mayflower Compact while on the ship, The Mayflower, that sailed from Holland to Plymouth Rock in the New World. 11/18/2002  Richard Warren was the 13th signer of the Mayflower Compact.
Richard Warren is an ancestor to many famous Americans.  Among them are Presidents Ulyssses S. Grant and Franklin D. Roosevelt; and Alan B. Shepard, Jr., the first American in space and fifth man to walk on the moon.   I had been wondering if she were a relative.  Our oral history is that our grandfather, Frank Hugh Robinson, said that one of his father, Abiathar Smith Robinson's sons had married an Indian princess.  I haven't been able to locate that piece of lore.  It's amazing that wikipedia neglected to list this man in their list of Warrens, so important to American history.  

What Elizabeth should have done before she told people that she was a native American was to have documentation through her family tree that this was true.  Then she should have followed it up with today's DNA testing, either at 23&Me, Family Tree DNA's familyfinder test,  or Ancestry which then could be shared with GedMatch to authenticate such a claim, since DNA tests would show this.  One wonders why she felt it necessary to tell people this whopper.  Was it to gain something?  Obviously, but what, favors? 

My Robinson 1st cousin matches both a Warren and a Reed as 5th cousins.  I do not know their histories, but this is interesting. 
The way we are connected to Richard Warren is explained in my notes from : 5/10/12: He is my brother, David and my 9th great grandfather this way;
Richard Warren to  his daughter Sarah Warren, Mary Cooke, Sarah Taber, Sarah Corey, Abraham Brown, Mary Brown who married Reverend Martin Tuller, 1st cousin 3 X removed from our great grandmother, Julia Ann Tuller of Royalton, Vermont.  Julia Ann Tuller was our great grandfather, Abiathar Smith Robinson's wife, parents of Frank Hugh Robinson who was born in Illinois.    

We're having trouble believing a lot of candidates for President.  Now we can't trust someone who lies about their ethnicity.  Politicians.  Won't they ever learn?  
Resource: CNN News
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Warren
https://collection.cooperhewitt.org/people/18050679/bio
https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2012/10/24/elizabeth-warren-family/p5wtcbsS90aTsHwKZKWj1N/story.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_(name)
https://familysearch.org/wiki/en/American_Indian_Online_Genealogy_Records
http://www.ctmayflower.org/mayflower_compact.php



Labels: , , , ,


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?