Robinson Genealogy

Nadene Goldfoot                                          
Ah, shucks.  It has taken DNA matches to veer me straight into Abiathar Smith Robinson's father and he isn't a John after all.  It has to be Israel Robinson born in 1800 which isn't far off of the pre-thought John Robinson, living in Julia Ann Tuller's home in 1850 in Royalton Vermont that I thought might be his father.  This line is connected to the 17 Bartletts we have, and a lot of Smiths connected to them.  It was the Robinson and Bartlett surnames that led me to someone I had matched several years ago on 23& Me, and now we had both moved over to Family Tree DNA and have been really working on it.  Between here and GedMatch and trying our hand at triangulation with another match, we finally found a connection on the tree.

The oral history of Abiathar coming from NY seems to hold water now.  I don't know what I"ll do about other stories like the Rix part of the family.  Maybe that will connect.  One can see from this tree that people had more than 2 children long ago, so maybe there's also another path other than all this one that will connect.

No, Israel is going to head straight to THE JOHN RobinsonREVEREND and BRIDGET WHITE who sent Pilgrims living in Holland to America on the Mayflower after all.  What I'm going to do about our DNA DYS 393 being a 12, and not a 13, I don't know.  but we match a DNA match found on FTDNA, and this is science.  I cannot ignore this match that we have with myself, my brother and 1st male cousin.  We're collecting more matches besides to ultimately connect to our tree through DNA.  I'll show our tree from Major Ebenezer Robinson:
PS, I see this line also holds another try at Abiathar's father where I show Abiathar in blue.  I once thought that the James Robinson could have been his father.  
                                                                   
Descendants of Ebenezer Robinson, Major

1   Ebenezer Robinson, Major b: February 07, 1735/36 in Rehoboth, Bristol, Massachusetts Bay, English Colony d: February 16, 1802 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York
.. +Ann Susanna Stone b: April 1741 in Framingham d: December 25, 1783
. 2   Ann Robinson b: Bef. June 05, 1757 in Carmel, Putnam, New York
. 2   Issachar Robinson b: April 26, 1761 in Frederickstown, Dutchess, New York d: February 06, 1850 in Middletown, Delaware, New York
..... +Huldah Willard b: 1768 in Pittstown, Rensselaer, New York d: 1800 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York
..... 3   Susanna Robinson b: Abt. 1783 d: 1855
......... +John Woolheater b: Abt. 1791
..... 3   Anna Robinson b: Abt. 1784
......... +Dingee Adams b: Abt. 1782
..... 3   Hannah Robinson b: Abt. 1785
......... +Ebenezer Sloat b: Abt. 1785
..... 3   Lewis Robinson b: Abt. 1787 d: in Lost At Sea
..... 3   Phoebe Robinson b: Abt. 1789
......... +Samuel Jenkins b: Abt. 1789
..... 3   James Robinson b: 1794 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: February 17, 1869 in Delaware, New York
......... +Elizabeth "Betsey" Redmond b: 1796 in New York d: in Delaware, New York
......... 4   [1] Patrick Robinson b: Abt. 1816 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: July 08, 1896 in Ulster, New York
............. +Melinda Ingraham b: 1825 in New York
......... *2nd Wife of [1] Patrick Robinson:
............. +Mary b: Abt. 1815 in New York
......... 4   Nicholas Robinson b: Abt. 1820 in Delaware County, New York d: June 19, 1864 in Point Lookout, Maryland
............. +Emaline Unknown b: Abt. 1820 in New York
......... 4   John R. Robinson b: Abt. 1821
......... 4   Harriet Robinson b: 1834 in New York
......... 4   Margaret Robinson b: Abt. 1837 in New York
..... 3   Daniel G. Robinson b: 1796 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: 1862
......... +Sophia Randall b: September 19, 1799 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware, New York
......... 4   Mary Robinson b: 1829 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York

Abiathar Smith Robinson with my grandfather, Frank Hugh Robinson

......... 4   [2] Abiathar Smith Robinson b: December 1829 in New York/  Tunbridge, Orange/ Jamaica,  Windham, Vermont d: October 07, 1904 in Wenona, Marshall, Illinois
............. +[5] Julia Ann Tuller b: December 18, 1834 in Royalton, Windsor, Vermont d: December 02, 1887 in 52 yrs, 11mo. 14 day, Wenona, Marshall, Illinois
......... *2nd Wife of [2] Abiathar Smith Robinson:
............. +[6] Mary Jane Unknown Walters b: November 1832 in Ohio d: July 1918 in Streator, Illinois, age 85
......... 4   Irena Robinson b: 1835 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York
......... 4   Abigail Robinson b: 1839 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York
......... 4   Anna Robinson b: 1842 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York
......... 4   John H. Robinson b: 1844 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York d: March 29, 1863 in Alexandria, Fairfax, Virginia
..... 3   Catherine Robinson b: 1800 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: April 18, 1873 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York
......... +Samuel Vermilyea b: January 08, 1793 in prob. Roxbury, New York d: April 09, 1852 in prob. Roxbury, Delaware County, New York
..... 3   Elizabeth "Betsy" Robinson b: 1805
......... +Nathaniel Jenkins b: Abt. 1805
. 2   Ebenezer Louis Robinson, Jr. b: 1763 in Carmel, Putnam, New York d: Aft. 1805 in Ulster, New York
..... +Whippie b: Abt. 1763
. 2   Nathaniel Robinson b: 1763 d: Aft. 1785
..... +Fanny Burcham b: Abt. 1763
. 2   David Robinson, Rev. b: March 09, 1763 in Carmel, Putnam, New York d: February 26, 1835 in Virgil, Cortland, New York
..... +Elizabeth "Althea" Hunt b: January 15, 1769 in Virgil, Cortland, New York d: September 17, 1850 in Virgil, Cortland, New York
..... 3   Jemima Robinson b: April 25, 1786 in probably Roxbury, New York d: 1865 in Virgil, Cortland, New York
..... 3   Edward Robinson b: July 04, 1792 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: 1840
..... 3   Edmund Hunt Robinson b: September 07, 1793 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: August 27, 1851 in New York
......... +Mary (Polly) Elstor b: December 15, 1795 in Dover, Dutchess, New York d: August 13, 1872 in Makanda, Jackson, Illinois
..... 3   Isaac Robinson b: March 04, 1798 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: 1840
..... 3   [3] Gideon Robinson b: August 13, 1800 in Roxbury, Delaware, New York d: March 27, 1864 in Virgil, Cortland, New York
......... +Mary (Polly) Hammond b: August 04, 1800 in Burlingame, New York d: July 04, 1854 in Virgil, Cortland, New York
......... 4   Orin Oren Robinson b: January 31, 1824 in New York d: October 18, 1883 in Kansas
............. +Emily Shepherd b: Abt. 1838 in Ohio d: 1909
......... 4   Alvin Robinson b: May 31, 1830 in Cortland, New York d: March 09, 1906 in Danville, Vermillion, Illinois
............. +Mary Minerva Price b: March 1831 in New York d: 1914
......... 4   Charles Robinson b: July 13, 1834 in New York
......... 4   Sarah Robinson b: 1840 in New York
......... 4   Jasper Peck Robinson b: February 04, 1841 in New York d: April 10, 1916 in Topeka, Wd 5, Shawnee, Kansas
............. +Sarah Parsons b: 1846 in New York d: 1896 in Topeka, Wd 5, Shawnee, Kansas
..... *2nd Wife of [3] Gideon Robinson:
......... +Elizabeth b: 1810
......... 4   Harriet Robinson b: 1844
. 2   Stephen Robinson b: April 04, 1769 in Carmel, Putnam, New York d: September 13, 1832 in Bedford, Cuyahoga, Ohio
. 2   Hester Robinson b: 1774 d: 1782
..... +Samuel Bouton b: Abt. 1770
. 2   [4] DANIEL Robinson, Rev. b: March 22, 1771 in Carmel, Putnam, New York d: January 27, 1866 in Kattellville, Broome, Schoharie, New York
..... +Elizabeth Unknown Hall b: 1785 in Rhode Island
. *2nd Wife of [4] DANIEL Robinson, Rev.:
..... +Sarah Dodge b: Abt. 1771 d: June 01, 1801
. *3rd Wife of [4] DANIEL Robinson, Rev.:
..... +Susan Kelly b: Abt. 1771
..... 3   John Robinson b: Abt. 1792 in poss. New York d: 1840 in Virginia
..... 3   Alva Robinson b: Abt. 1793 in New York
..... 3   Nehemiah Robinson b: Abt. 1794
..... 3   ISRAEL ROBINSON b: April 20, 1800 in Roxbury, Delaware , NY d: November 05, 1857 in Chenango, Broome, NY
......... +Catherine Tracy b: 1800 in NY d: August 05, 1882 in Broome, New York
......... 4   EBENEZER GANONG Robinson b: May 1823 in Dutchess County, New York d: Aft. 1900 in Clark County, Washington
............. +Julia Ann Morse b: June 05, 1828 in Roxbury, Delaware, NY d: 1916 in Clark County, Washington
......... 4   Nathaniel Robinson b: 1825 in New York d: 1906 in Kattellville, Broome, New York
............. +Lavania Keeler b: 1829 in New York d: 1918 in Kattellville, Broome, New York
......... 4   JOHN K. ROBINSON b: Abt. 1826 in poss. Dutchess, New York d: in poss. Washington
............. +Lucinda Haskins b: Abt. 1830 d: in prob. Washington
......... 4   [2] Abiathar Smith Robinson b: December 1829 in New York/  Tunbridge, Orange/ Jamaica, Windham, Vermont d: October 07, 1904 in Wenona, Marshall, Illinois
............. +[5] Julia Ann Tuller b: December 18, 1834 in Royalton, Windsor, Vermont d: December 02, 1887 in 52 yrs, 11mo. 14 day, Wenona, Marshall, Illinois
......... *2nd Wife of [2] Abiathar Smith Robinson:
............. +[6] Mary Jane Unknown Walters b: November 1832 in Ohio d: July 1918 in Streator, Illinois, age 85
......... 4   Susan C. Robinson b: 1838 in New York
..... 3   Lewis Robinson b: October 27, 1802 in Roxbury, Delaware/ prob, NY
..... 3   Daniel Robinson b: December 18, 1804 d: January 21, 1864 in Kattelville, Broome, New York
..... 3   Mary Robinson b: November 07, 1807 in Otsego, New York d: April 13, 1854 in Kattelville, Brome, New York
..... 3   Charlotte Robinson b: September 01, 1814 in Franklin, New York

Some people don't understand why we pursue such a hobby as genealogy.  Well, it's personal.  It's our family and who we come from.  It's why we laugh or cry, feel nervous or sad or happy.  We are made up of certain people throughout the ages and inherit some of their traits as well as their faults, problems, etc.  Now, the finding of others, knowing we share something of ourselves with them, is detective work.  It's solving a puzzle work.  It's so exciting to track down a clue.  The ultimate now is to have their picture and information automatically click into my tree once I find where they belong on my FTDNA tree !